posted 10/07/09 07:35 AM | updated 10/07/09 11:41 AM

Can the First Hill/Capitol Hill Streetcar run in a loop? UPDATED

Below, via a speedy E-mail from S-DOT's Ethan Melone, are the rules for the recently funded First Hill Streetcar project, issued on October 5th.

Note especially the requirement for double-tracking:

The Project will be double-tracked, although termini or exclusive-lane segments may feature a short segment of single track if this will not impede service objectives.

Wikipedia:


double track railway usually involves running one track in each direction, compared to a single track railway where trains in both directions share the same track.

Will the double-tracking requirement make the plans for a loop route impossible? A single-track system obviously just has one set of rails and the trains shuttle back and forth. If the two sets of tracks are on separate streets, does that count as a double-track system? The wikipedia article mentions some "non-parallel" double-track systems, but those were constrained by geography.  My thanks to Jim Erickson of First Hill for pointing out this issue.


Updates:

Andrew: is the double-tracking requirement compatible with the desires of  some neighborhoods to have  a loop route?

Ethan Melone: Yes, this just means we won't have a single track arrangement, like the Waterfront Streetcar.

Jim Erickson: Another factor in this discussion is the water pipeline under the northbound lanes of 12th Avenue. See FHIA's July notes:  http://www.firsthill.org/meetinghighlights.html  The Cedar River water pipeline runs under the northbound lanes of 12th Avenue, thus precluding any streetcar construction over those lanes. Any streetcar routing on 12th would have to go in the southbound lanes, or have a dedicated lane in the middle of the street. 


Exhibit A: Minimum Scope of Work for First Hill Streetcar Connector Project

 The purpose of the First Hill Streetcar Connector Project (the Project) is to replace the connection to the regional Link light rail system lost when the First Hill light rail station was deleted from the regional system. The streetcar connector will directly connect First Hill employment centers to the regional Link light rail system at the International District/Chinatown Station at 5th Avenue S and the Capitol Hill Station at Broadway between E. Denny Way and John Street.  If operations begin prior to July 1, 2016, the Project may feature an interim terminus in the vicinity of Pike and Pine streets.

 The Project fleet (inclusive of at least one spare vehicle) and facilities will accommodate the service plan:

  1. Service Plan

    1. Service Plan: Span of Service 

    Monday-Saturday 5AM to 1AM

     

    2. Service Plan: Peak/Off Peak Headways

    Peak Periods: Trains Arrive Every 10 Minutes

    Off Peak: Trains Arrive Every 15 Minutes

     

    3. Service Plan: Peak Service Periods

    Peak Periods: 6AM-9AM M-F, 4PM-7PM M-F

The service plan may be adjusted with the written concurrence of Sound Transit.

 The Project will provide local and inter-neighborhood transit service using modern low-floor light rail vehicles, similar to the streetcar vehicles operating in Portland, Seattle and Tacoma.  The streetcars operate in single trainsets.  The streetcars will generally operate in a mixed flow of traffic on urban arterial streets, typically with transit signal priority at intersections, and  occasionally operating in restricted (transit-only) lanes or exclusive right-of-way.  The Project will be double-tracked, although termini or exclusive-lane segments may feature a short segment of single track if this will not impede service objectives.

The Project will meet or exceed all accessibility requirements and includes a variety of passenger amenities on board, at passenger platforms and on the internet, including transit shelters, real-time arrival information, automated passenger information, and wayside and on-board ticketing.  Use of the ORCA regional smart card will be accommodated either on-board, wayside, or with both of these methods of fare payment.

Passenger platforms will typically be spaced at distances of 1,250 to 2,000 feet and will be sited to best balance proximity of service to major activity areas with speed and reliability objectives.

 The Project will include all construction, right-of-way and equipment necessary to meet the service objectives, including but not limited to:

 

  • paved track and special track;
  •  traction power system and overhead contact system;
  • train control system and train signaling;
  • passenger platforms and amenities including miscellaneous electrical service to   amenities;
  • a light maintenance and vehicle storage facility and vehicle maintenance equipment;
  •  roadway and drainage modifications;
  • traffic signal modifications;
  • street lighting modifications;
  • utility relocation, protection and bridging necessitated by the Project;
  • relocation of overhead trolley bus wires where necessary;
  • mitigation measures; and
  •  an Art Program.

 

The Art Program will be administered by the City and is budgeted at $750,000 in 2011 dollars to represent approximately 1% of estimated construction expenditure.

 The Project will be designed to allow for connections to other segments of the City's planned streetcar network and may include extensions beyond the minimum scope of work.

Add Your Comment ( 5 )
Name:
Email:
(will not be displayed)
Subject:
Comment:
or

So the answer is...
So the updated answer from Ethan Melone is, YES, the First Hill/Capitol Hill Streetcar can run in a loop.

Thanks for your concern, Jim Erickson. The question troubled me, too, until someone explained to me what a single-track streetcar was. Ethan Melone has also clarified in the updated post that a First Hill/Capitol Hill Streetcar that follows a loop route is still a double-track streetcar.
Comment by trellis
October 08, 2009
Yes but
It will significantly increase cost. From what I understand a 12th ave loop will have trains running one way on 12th and one way on Broadway, not both ways on both streets. If they run both ways on both streets that will roughly double construction costs.

I understand that some people see money for a streetcar and recent 12th ave development and put the two together and think that the streetcar should go down 12th but that was never the purpose of the 12th ave streetcar. The sole reason there is money for the streetcar is because ST dropped the first hill light rail station. Any new streetcar should must meet the travel that the first hill station would have otherwise meet.

Think about it this way. It is like giving a kid candy because he scraped his knee, but then the kid next to him steals it because he likes candy. Lets not steal candy from our fellow neighbors on the hill.
Comment by Adam Parast
October 09, 2009
RE: Yes but
Except its not so simple a matter as "meet[ing] the travel that the first hill station would have otherwise [met]." A First Hill light rail station would have primarily addressed the job centers on FH and provided a link to an efficient, high-speed regional train. A secondary benefit would have been links for FH residents to other neighborhoods in Seattle.

The First Hill street car, by virtue of it being a street car and not light rail, will not provide the same quick and seamless connection to FH. Street cars are not commuter trains, at least not unless they have dedicated ROWs, signal priority and limited service runs (i.e. fewer stops during peak hours). The FHSC could be planned primarily as commuter train even without the above, but it won't come close to hitting ridership. Employees on FH will chose quicker connections to light rail after they are stuck in traffic on Boren. Walking to any of the downtown stations will prove to be quicker and more dependable during peak hours. Does this candy really do anything to address the scraped knee?

A loop route won't make the commute to FH any quicker. That's not its intention. The loop route's intention is connectivity in and between neighborhoods. Its about increased service capacity in under-served and poorly connected areas. Its about strengthening neighborhood retail cores and, guiding future development and investment. Its about dissipating the streetcar's impact on arterials. And its about promoting increased access and interaction between residents in First Hill, Pike Pine, Capitol Hill, the ID and the Central Area.

The... read more
Comment by dang
October 09, 2009
RE: Yes but
@ Dang

If you go back and read ST2 it says something different ( http://future.soundtransit.org/documents/ST2_Plan_web.pdf p.10).

" ST2 also includes a new streetcar connector line between Downtown Seattle, First Hill and the
future Capitol Hill light rail station. The new connector will also provide convenient access to the
Sounder commuter rail system and regional bus services. "

12th Ave is not part of First Hill. I appreciate and agree with the sentiment that streetcars should be use to connect neighborhoods and that is exactly what the Broadway or Boren alignment will do.

What really bothers me with the 12th Ave idea is that in the effort to improve connectivity of one part of a neighborhood you hurting the other parts of the Hill, both of which are the historic centers of activity of life.
Comment by Adam Parast
October 12, 2009
I want to echo Adam's comment here.
Going from two ways on Broadway to a loop line would both reduce the line's ridership (you'd have only one direction of service to the employment center) and increase cost. You'd have to do utility relocations on the other street.

Adding cost to decrease ridership is usually a bad idea, and this case is no exception.
Comment by Ben Schiendelman
October 13, 2009